A Planning Playbook for Opening a New Orthopedic ASC
The ASC market continues its rapid growth. In 2023, roughly 116 new ASCs opened in the U.S., many of which were orthopedic-specific in nature....
This website uses cookies. to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalized ads or content, and analyze our traffic. By clicking “Accept & Close”, you consent to our use of cookies. Read our Privacy Policy to learn more.
By: Dianne Taylor
Published: 10/10/2007
For outpatient facilities that perform cataract extractions, adversity has proved fruitful in many ways. Declining or stagnating reimbursements have, in part, fueled new surgical approaches that have hastened the procedure, reduced morbidity and improved overall efficiency. Yet, as financial pressures continue to mount, many worry that the breaking point is drawing uncomfortably near. According to an Outpatient Surgery survey of 97 readers, two-thirds are "very concerned" and another one-fourth are "somewhat concerned" about maintaining the profitability of cataract surgery in the coming five years.
This widespread concern stems from a host of factors, including the continued squeeze on facility reimbursements, rising RN payrolls, local competition and pressure to adopt expensive new technologies - particularly the pricier new IOLs. ASCs saw no increase in the Medicare facility fee for cataract extraction this year, and MedPAC is expected to recommend a freeze on the payment through 2009, according to the Outpatient Ophthalmic Surgery Society (OOSS). Hospitals received about a 22 percent increase during the past two years, but they're still reeling from deep cuts during prior years- including an 18 percent reduction between 2001 and 2002 alone, according to OOSS.
One nonprofit hospital's surgical services director, who is faced with the unique challenge of reducing her surgical load because she's running over capacity, says cataract surgery is her No. 1 target because it's not profitable. Her ophthalmic surgeons will be subject to economic credentialing. "If they can't help reduce costs and at least break even," she says, "they'll lose their blocks and compete for unblocked time. We have the same expectation for all services. It's the only way the hospital can survive."
Still, the majority of our responders from all outpatient settings say they're managing to hang in - at least for now. A full 59 percent report cataract extractions are "somewhat" or "very" profitable compared with other procedures. The reason, they say, is aggressive cost-cutting, achieved by shortening the patient stay/OR time, negotiating firmly with vendors, avoiding supply waste, and ensuring staff proficiency. The majority do 2.5 to 3 procedures per OR per hour, with some doing as many as five, using standardized supplies. Our readers' experiences suggest that most, if not all, of these factors need to be in play simultaneously. One hospital reader noted, for example, that he has not achieved profitability despite an hourly volume of 5 to 6 cases per OR because physicians won't standardize.
|
How readers maintain profitability
Responders working to improve cataract surgery profitability point to three key target areas: Supply costs, volume and patient throughput.
A specific area of concern is IOL cost. At Garrett County Memorial Hospital in Oakland, Md., where surgeons do 20 cases per month, Nurse Manager JoAnn Forno consolidated to lower costs. "We use one IOL and other products from the same vendor," she says. The Ocala (Fla.) Eye Surgery Center, where surgeons do up to 350 cataract extractions per month, is using the opposite strategy, moving away from single-sourcing and inviting additional vendors in to stir up competition. Some other facilities are specifically avoiding high-priced IOLs. One recently 'downgraded' its IOL model, and another manager says her surgeons "don't always use the newest technology lenses." Still others, like Ms. Acker, where cataracts remain "very profitable," are finding ways (like standardization) to offset rising IOL costs because they feel the new implants are in the patient's best interest.
Several other responders point to new phaco machines as recruitment incentives. At the Hinsdale (Ill.) Surgical Center, Executive Director Shirley Zemansky believes her brand new phaco machines will aid her recruitment effort. Another hospital reader says the speed of his new phaco machine, in and of itself, translates into more cases per day.
Many are reducing the time needed to administer eye drops by moving to all-in-one dilating preparations or sponges, or by better organizing multi-dose regimens. "We streamline the process by having a Ziploc bag with the assortment of pre-op drops each surgeon uses," says Ms. Brunswick.
Responders from all settings keep patients in street clothes and on the same gurney throughout the experience. "We finally followed the example of the ASCs and no longer require our patients to completely disrobe," says Kathy Simmons, RN, MS, perioperative supervisor with Clearfield Hospital in Clearfield, Pa., where cataract patients bypass pre-op holding and phase one PACU. Some hospital-based readers, like Jayne Byrd, director of surgical services with Raleigh, N.C.-based Rex Hospital, are considering moving out of the OR altogether into a procedure-room environment.
Finally, to stay in the game, several small hospitals have invited companies in who supply all the capital equipment, supplies and personnel for cataract surgery. "They furnish all equipment in total plus a tech," says a Minnesota OR director. "As a small hospital, we could not keep up with the technology." Cyndy Harting, of Audrain Medical Center, in Mexico, Mo., says she is also considering such a service.
Challenging future ahead
Despite these successes, the enthusiasm of our responders is tinged with concern. At the Blake Woods facility, where ophthalmology is 75 percent of her business, Ms. Acker said her healthcare benefit rose 17 percent last year, payroll for existing employees rose 5 percent and IOL costs rose $15 per case. Simply put, she concludes: "I am very concerned."
The ASC market continues its rapid growth. In 2023, roughly 116 new ASCs opened in the U.S., many of which were orthopedic-specific in nature....
In her 24 years as a nurse at Penn Medicine, Connie Croce has seen the evolution from open to laparoscopic to robotic surgery....
Through my decades of researching, testing and helping implement healthcare design solutions, I’ve learned an important lesson: A human-centered and evidence-based...