Shopping for a GPO

Share:

Five questions every OR manager needs to ask before joining a group purchasing organization.


Imagine walking into a supply warehouse with a blank check, a day to kill and an idling truck waiting outside. Whatever you'd want, you'd get without thinking for a second about prices. Sutures? Grab as many as you can. Latex-free gloves? Will a skid tide you over? Some skin prep kits? Sure, back up the truck.

If only. In the fixed-cost world of surgery, where supplies are your biggest expense next to staff, it's probably a better idea to shop for medical inventory with an eye on the bottom line.

A group purchasing organization can be your best personal shopper, yet all GPOs are not created equal, and it takes a shrewd administrator to find the one that works best for her center. Here are five questions to ask before joining a GPO.

1. Do I pay a monthly fee to participate in the GPO? Refuse double-dipping. GPOs make money from their contracted vendors based on the amount you spend on each vendor's contract. You should never pay a monthly fee for the GPO's contracts, because the vendor is paying the GPO a fee for every dollar you spend with it. If there's a fee in sight, move on with your shopping (see "A Sampling of Your GPO Choices" on page 60).

2. Are the vendors I use among the GPO's contracts? In your search for the best match, ask the GPO representative to give you a list of its current contracted vendors. Ask when each contract expires and what the GPO is doing to renegotiate that contract. Take the GPO's list and compare it to your current vendor list. If the GPO doesn't have 90 percent or more of the same vendors you have contracted, ask if it's negotiating or willing to negotiate to add that vendor to its contract portfolio. If the answer's no, continue shopping.

3. Are the GPO's contract prices with these vendors better than those you've negotiated on your own? This next compare-and-contrast step will tell you if you're saving or spending more with a GPO. First, identify the top 25 products to 50 products you purchase. Place them on an Excel spreadsheet and note the current price you pay per item. In the next column, insert the GPO's negotiated price for the same item. In the third column, note the difference between the two amounts. Share your findings with your prospective GPO to see if the products you're already buying at a lower cost can be renegotiated in their contract. If you've negotiated lower prices on your own, you should have the option to decline a contract within your GPO contractual agreement.

Why would you use a GPO if you were better than they are at negotiating the best price? The answer is simple: If you find the GPO saves you money on 95 percent of your center's high-volume items, then strongly consider signing on. If not, keep shopping.

A Sampling of Your GPO Choices

The growing number of dedicated ambulatory surgery service divisions among the nation's best known purchasing organizations underscores outpatient surgery's value to group purchasing organizations. Here's a sampling of nine GPOs that focus on the outpatient setting.

- Compiled by Daniel Cook


AllHealth
(800) 377-8200
www.all-health.com
CAPSULE: AllHealth Group Purchasing, which serves 1,200 healthcare organizations in the mid-Atlantic region, combines national buying power with local customer service to cost-effectively meet the supply needs of facilities, says the company. AllHealth provides access to the industry's contracts through its partnership with HealthCare Purchasing Partners International, the sister company of Novation. AllHealth works with facilities in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, Virginia, West Virginia, central and western New York, and Washington, D.C.


Amerinet
(800) 388-2638
www.amerinet-gpo.com
CAPSULE: Healthcare GPO Amerinet says it partners with members to improve their operating margins. Amerinet is flexible with a commitment to providing supplier choice for its members, says the company. Its national network of companies - Amerinet Central, Intermountain Health Care and Vector - has provided customer service for nearly two decades. More than 1,860 hospitals and 21,000 non-acute care facilities find cost savings and value-added services through Amerinet's comprehensive contract portfolio.


Broadlane
(866) BROADLN
www.broadlane.com
CAPSULE: Broadlane delivers pricing, service and coverage that the company says outpaces the performance of traditional GPOs. The company claims $7.4 billion in buying power from its committed nationwide customer base. It also claims to facilitate clinical consensus and negotiate high-value product and distribution agreements. The company says its high-value contracting portfolio lets it deliver prices that are among the best in the industry. For most customers, Broadlane states it delivers double-digit savings on total supply purchases.


HealthTrust
Purchasing Group
(615) 344-3000
www.healthtrustpg.com
CAPSULE: HealthTrust Purchasing Group is a GPO that supports not-for-profit and for-profit acute care hospitals, ambulatory surgery centers, alternate care sites and physician practices. With an annual purchasing volume of more than $6 billion, HPG is committed to obtaining the best price for clinically recommended products, ensuring their timely delivery and continuously evaluating and improving its services to patients, physicians and clinicians, says the company.

4. Are the GPO's contracts user-friendly? Consider ease of use in accessing the GPO's contracts. Can you simply sign the agreement and note what level of products you'll buy each year? Or do you have to sign the contract and enter all your required items with guarantees of monthly purchases? If you find the contract restrictive, continue shopping.

Before you sign on with a GPO, ask about its maintenance agreements and ongoing support services that will ease your administrative burden. Does the GPO provide education about new products on the market? Does it send you alerts on price increases and alternative products to try? Does it seek your opinion on contracts you need it to negotiate? What does the GPO service rep do for you on a weekly or monthly basis? Does he come to your office and compare your invoices to contract prices to assure you're billed correctly? Does the GPO provide online service and product information? Does it track the volume of goods you purchase on contract? Will it teach your staff how to use its network to obtain product information? If you answer "no" to most of those questions, keep shopping.

5. What other services and support does the GPO offer to keep costs down? You're looking for a business partner. Top GPOs can be key allies in helping surgery departments resolve some of your most critical issues, including contract versus non-contract utilization; high volume of purchase orders; cost control per procedure; commodity; pharmaceutical, implant and physician preference; lack of inventory management tools; lack of benchmarks for capital equipment cost and supply cost per case; lack of educated staff who understand supply-chain management and the purchasing process; added pressure on staffing shortages; and the essential need for standardization.

The best GPO provider for you is the one that delivers contract maintenance, cost management/price controls, assistance in developing wholesaler/distributor relationships and assistance in developing vendor/supplier relationships.

When a GPO provides these services, you've found a business partner that understands your supply needs, delivers cost management and has an IT system that keeps you updated on your supply contracts and pricing. Your GPO should also generate e-reports on contract utilization, product volume, audits and rebate tracking (if you have rebates coming).

A Sampling of Your GPO Choices

The growing number of dedicated ambulatory surgery service divisions among the nation's best known purchasing organizations underscores outpatient surgery's value to group purchasing organizations. Here's a sampling of nine GPOs that focus on the outpatient setting.

- Compiled by Daniel Cook


Hospital Purchasing Service
(269) 795-3308
www.hpsnet.com
CAPSULE: Hospital Purchasing Service, headquartered in Middleville, Mich., is a super-regional GPO owned and operated by its member institutions, says the company. Members/participants of HPS represent both not-for-profit as well as for-profit organizations. In addition to a comprehensive agreement portfolio for the purchase of goods and supplies, HPS also serves as a dealer for capital equipment. HPS has been in business for more than 55 years and services more than 2,300 organizations.


MedAssets
(800) 950-4722
www.medassets.com
CAPSULE: MedAssets improves healthcare providers' margins and cash flow through revenue cycle and supply chain initiatives by using proprietary information technology that works with and improves upon existing IT assets and work processes, says the company. MedAssets is focused on providing aggressive contracts and innovative technology including CDQuick, a web-based contract catalog. The company says CDQuick lets facilities truly manage their supply chain by measuring contract and price compliance, and uncovering savings opportunities.


Novation
(888) 7-NOVATE
www.novationco.com
CAPSULE: Novation says its mission is to provide industry-leading supply chain management solutions that assist members in improving and sustaining their performance. Through its affiliation with VHA and UHC, Novation serves the purchasing needs of more than 2,300 members and affiliates, managing more than $23 billion in annual purchases in 2004, says the company. The company serves healthcare organizations of all sizes, ranging from many of the nation"s best-known and most prestigious healthcare systems to small, rural hospitals throughout the country.




Premier, Inc.
(877) 777.1552
www.premierinc.com)
CAPSULE: Serving 1,500 of the nation"s hospitals and healthcare systems and thousands of outpatient and alternate care sites, Premier, Inc., provides an array of performance improvement resources including group purchasing of more than $21 billion annually in supplies and equipment, says the company. Premier"s alternate-site healthcare program offers reduced prices on pharmaceuticals and medical supplies to outpatient surgery centers and other non-acute providers. Premier also offers supply chain and clinical consulting, performance measurement and reporting solutions and insurance programs.



Surgery Center Consultants
(770) 939-2799
www.surgcent.com
CAPSULE: Surgery Center Consultants offers freestanding and office-based surgery centers a group purchasing program that provides cost reductions in all areas of product management. Founded by Jennie Simmons, RN, CPSN, the company says it is able to offer facilities a wide range of products at significant savings - everything from custom packs to instruments. Membership in the GPO is free. In addition to group purchasing, Surgery Center Consultants helps surgical facilities meet licensure, certification and accreditation requirements.

On the Web

Click here to download a Sample Par Level Supply Sheet.

Holding up your end
Choosing the right GPO is key to driving down supply costs, but so is the effort you make to service the contract on your end. There are four key components in decreasing your costs for medical supplies: Use the GPO that best serves your center's needs, educate your physicians and nurses about supply costs, purchase supplies by walking around, and develop par levels for every item purchased and stored in the center.

The best administrators manage by walking around, and the same is true for purchasing techs. Have them check par levels daily to assure you're not below the minimum inventory you keep on the shelf. Set up a standard day or days of the week to purchase most of your supplies. While there are always emergencies that require you to order off-schedule, insist on keeping the number of purchase orders to a minimum. Each purchase order costs you money in time, payment processing and recording of the payment once received.

Set a standard for having cases pulled 72 hours in advance. This practice helps decrease the volume of purchase orders and eliminates emergency shipping costs when something must be sent overnight. Teach your purchasing tech to run schedules for a minimum of seven days out and count the supplies (such as packs, tubing and implants) needed for each upcoming case. Then check the shelves for supplies on hand so that you only order the difference. Keep no more than 30 days of inventory in your surgery center at any time. This keeps your money in the bank and not gathering dust on your shelves.

One more detail is to develop par levels for every supply storage area. Teach your staff to stock by par level only. Audit their work to assure that they're not hoarding supplies. In the long run, hoarding actually costs the center money and can even generate waste.

Universal savings
In general, healthcare professionals primarily think of GPOs as valuable to hospitals and health systems. But the landscape has changed over the last two decades as outpatient facilities have gained enormous negotiating power. Whether you manage at a hospital's surgery center or at an ASC, your leverage is great and, through carefully focused shopping, your center can post valuable savings to its bottom line by signing with a GPO.

Once you select a GPO, continue to evaluate your contract by constantly asking for answers to the same questions you asked when choosing the company. If GPO vendor contracts change, or service to your center is diminishing, grab your basket and laundry list of questions and go shopping again.

Advice From a GPO User

In the year I've been involved with our GPO, I've saved anywhere from $1 to $40 per item on supplies. I've also tracked a 7 percent savings on IV catheters, 16 percent savings on IV tubing and a whopping 48 percent decrease on my cost of sutures.

Like any service or piece of equipment you rely on at your facility, the GPO you choose must be user-friendly to be truly effective. That starts with the compatibility - both professionally and personally - that you have with the company's contact. Ask prospective GPO reps for a face-to-face interview because that's the only way to get a true feel for the chemistry you share.

Conduct the interview at your facility; this will let you see who's willing to spend time with you, and that will provide an indication as to how committed the GPO is to servicing your facility. A rep who can't get to your facility for an interview probably won't be around much to answer any questions or concerns you might have during the life of the GPO contract.

During these interviews, ask questions that will help you understand whom you'll be dealing with. I wanted to know the size and boundaries of a rep's territory. The closest rep of one company was two hours away and had to traverse the busiest interstate in Florida to get to our facility. How often would I see him? Not very often. I also wanted to know how flexible a company was with respect to getting me supplies in emergency situations. Par levels and pulling cases the night before surgery are all well and good, but we all know missing items are sometimes needed an hour before cut time. Could the GPO respond quickly enough to help me in that situation? I needed to know.

The GPO's delivery schedule is also a key consideration. I found a GPO with a truck in my area five days a week, so I'm able to have supplies delivered whenever I need them. Along those same lines, find out where the company's warehouse is located and make sure it's local. Also, if the GPO doesn't have a product you constantly use on stock at a local warehouse, is it willing to change that setup to meet your needs?

I found out which GPOs accept orders over the Internet and e-mail updates and changes to the product list. Staying current is essential, and you shouldn't have to work hard to get updates from companies. Finally, I asked how long the companies were in business and what other facilities they serve in my area. That gave me an idea as to which centers I could contact to get feedback from administrators about the company and its level of service. If a GPO isn't established in your vicinity, find out why.

Treat the face-to-face meetings with GPO reps like job interviews, because that's essentially what they are. The reps make a commission on anything they sell to you, so make sure they earn their money.

- Patrice Spera, RN, MS, CNOR, CRNFA

Ms. Spera ([email protected]) is the administrator of the Tampa Bay Specialty Surgery Center in Pinellas Park, Fla.