Keeping ‘Surgeon Athletes’ in the Game

Share:

Physicians who stay fit avoid ergonomic injuries, prolong their careers and deliver better patient care.


Surgeons are elite athletes in the operating room. They remain focused while executing precise maneuvers with complex instrumentation, and push through the pain of fatigued muscles and aching joints to complete the task at hand. A do-whatever-it-takes dedication to patient care often prevents surgeons from talking openly about their injuries. They instead suffer in silence through increasingly common pain in their neck, back, shoulders and arms. The situation is likely to worsen as minimally invasive procedures, which call for contorted hand and limb positions and awkward neck angles, gain in popularity. Fortunately, the attitude of pushing through the pain to complete the task is changing. There are simple and effective changes surgeons can make to prevent or reduce musculoskeletal issues caused by repetitive strain injuries.

Comfort measures

LOUPED IN Bright headlights and a light pair of loupes can prevent neck strain by making it easier for surgeons to keep their heads in a neutral position while operating.

Surgeons who use ergonomic equipment are well on their way to avoiding injury in the OR.

Lightweight loupes. Surgeons should invest in a set that is comfortable and with an angle of declination that keeps their head as close to a neutral position as possible. They should pay attention to the angle of their head as they perform surgery to help vendors in properly fitting them with a new pair. New loupes are available with a mirror built into the magnification piece that allows surgeons to look straight ahead in an ergonomically comfortable position while working and still see the surgical field below.

Comfortable headlights. The brighter the illumination, the better, and battery-operated models are preferable. Debilitating and potentially career-ending injuries can occur when a member of the surgical team accidentally steps or pulls on a cord that tethers the surgeon’s headlight to a power source. Battery packs for portable lights can be attached to the surgeon’s waistband or come integrated into the headset itself. I prefer having the battery pack on my waist because that makes the headset lighter. 

Form-fitting aprons. For years, surgeons often used whichever apron was available to protect themselves from radiation exposure during cases involving intraoperative imaging. When I finally got a custom-fit one, it made a big difference in my comfort level during surgery. Aprons that fit properly ensure that most of the weight is supported by your hips, not your shoulders. Ill-fitting aprons are often too heavy, offer less protection and alter the range of motion in your arms — all of which can affect a surgeon’s ability to do their job comfortably and precisely.

Ergonomic instruments. Surgeons have access to many different types of instruments to perform essentially the same surgical tasks. Being aware of how the tools work and feel in their hands, and realizing they have options in terms of tools designed with ergonomics in mind, can help them select instruments that will be more comfortable to use while they’re holding and manipulating them — especially during longer procedures. 

Although roughly 25% of current cardiothoracic trainees are female, practicing surgeons in this specialty currently make up only 7% of the workforce, and most surgical instruments are designed for larger, male hands. If I’m forced to use two hands to operate a larger instrument, I’m not embarrassed to do so because using one hand might cause undue muscle strain, which could ultimately result in a repetitive strain injury.

Ultimately, surgeons must always be on the lookout for instruments that rest comfortably in their hands, match their preferred operating style and are an overall ergonomic fit.

Footing and stance. Standing during surgery for hours on end can be grueling, so surgeons must concern themselves with softening the strain on their feet, knees and hips. Fluid-collecting anti-fatigue mats add some cushion to hard OR floors and limit stress on the lower limbs. Wearing supportive and comfortable shoes is also an effective way for surgeons to reduce discomfort in their feet and limit lower back pain.

Surgeons can achieve neutral body positions while operating by avoiding rotating their neck and not tilting it more than 15 degrees; occasionally shifting their weight from one foot to the other; limiting their hand reach to a maximum of 16 to 18 inches; keeping their hands between the waist and the middle of the chest; and positioning the angle of their elbows between 90 and 120 degrees. Taking a few minutes to prep the OR setup can help them maintain these comfortable positions during surgery.

Table height. Before the case begins, adjust the OR table to just below the surgeon’s elbows. This forces them to extend their arms slightly in order to operate and with their elbows in the targeted 90- to 120-degree range. Throughout surgery, the surgeon’s arms should be closer to a straight line than the more acutely bent “T-Rex” position. 

Monitors. Screens that hang around the sterile field are usually placed too high and too far away from the surgeon. Ideally, monitors should be positioned 80cm to 120cm from the surgeon’s eyes and between their eye level and hand positioning. Taking 30 seconds to adjust the position of monitors at the outset of the procedure will likely save you more than that amount of time during the case because surgeons won’t be constantly stopping to twist and contort themselves to see what’s on the screens. 

Step stools. You can’t always adjust the table to a height that’s perfect for everyone, so shorter surgeons shouldn’t be shy about using step stools to make sure their elbows are positioned in a way that promotes ergonomic comfort. Surgeons who need a stool — or two or three put together to create a larger platform for cases involving a wider surgical field — should take the time to position it correctly before the case starts to make sure they can access all areas of the patient easily and comfortably.

Simple Ways to Stretch and Strengthen for Surgery
EXERCISE ROUTINES
TAKING A BREAK Stepping away from the table, even for only a few seconds, to stretch your muscles can help you avert injuries over the long haul.

These are whenever-you-can-do-them regimens. Break your circuits into about three exercises each. If you rest for 30 seconds between each set, each circuit should take about 12 minutes. If you can’t do that many, for whatever reason, then do less.

Stretching exercises

Sternocleidomastoid muscle. Tilt your ear to shoulder; hold for five to 10 breaths on each side.

Chin tucks. Keep your shoulders still, face forward, pull your chin back without tilting your face, then release and allow your chin to float forward. Repeat five to 10 times.

Shoulder stretch. Cross one arm across your chest and push gently on your elbow with the other arm for a deep stretch; hold for two to five breaths each side.

Seated spinal twist. Sit on the floor in a cross-legged position. Twist to the right with your left hand on your right knee and place your right hand behind your back on the floor. Twist and look behind you as much as you can. Take a few deep breaths and switch your hands to twist to the left.

Trapezius stretch. Sitting on a chair, use one hand to hold the seat and the other to gently pull your head to the opposite side stretching your ear to the opposite shoulder. Hold for 15 seconds on each side.

Levator scapulae stretch. Bend your arm and place your hand on the ipsilateral shoulder so your elbow is pointed upwards. Look down toward your opposite hip. Place your opposite hand behind your head and gently pull down to deepen the stretch. Hold for 15 seconds on each side.

Cat-cow. Start on your hands and knees with a neutral spine. Inhale and arch your back, looking up (cow position), then exhale and round your back (cat position). Repeat for 10 slow breaths.

Strengthening exercises

Squats. Adjust your feet shoulder-width apart with your toes facing forward. 

Squat until your thighs are parallel to the floor. Do 15 reps with an optional hold.

Mountain climbers. Using a tall plank position, engage your core, and alternate bringing each knee up to your chest. Continue for 60 seconds. Consider increasing your speed to increase your heart rate.

Glute bridge. Lying on your back, bend your knees and keep your feet flat on the floor. Push your hips up until your knees, hips and shoulders are in a straight line. Do 15 reps.

Putting your body through regular stretching and strengthening routines will improve your overall health and by extension your performance in the OR. These exercises can be done at home, in the locker room or in the OR just before procedures begin. You can even take a minute during procedures to do some shoulder shrugs and shake your arms out. 

Barbara C.S. Hamilton, MD, MAS 

Selfless self-care

I don’t know of a single surgeon who hasn’t had to deal with a physical issue at some point during their time in the OR. Surgeons love what they do and should be able to operate in comfort until they decide they’re ready to call it quits. They shouldn’t be forced to the sideline because of an avoidable musculoskeletal injury. They must pay attention to the needs and demands of their bodies, as athletes do, to prevent injuries from shortening their careers.

Perhaps most importantly, surgical ergonomics is a patient care issue. If a surgeon’s back and neck are hurting while they’re operating, they can easily become distracted by the pain. If they’re good at what they do and are on leave to rehab an injury, their expertise is missed. If they must retire early, their mentorship and experience are lost for others.

Surgeons need to shift their mentality about their own well-being and begin to think about staying in the best possible physical shape to provide the best possible patient care. OSM

Related Articles

Wired for Success

In her 24 years as a nurse at Penn Medicine, Connie Croce has seen the evolution from open to laparoscopic to robotic surgery....

To Optimize OR Design, Put People First

Through my decades of researching, testing and helping implement healthcare design solutions, I’ve learned an important lesson: A human-centered and evidence-based...