A Show of Hands on Surgical Gloves

Share:

Here"s what you told us about how you buy this essential supply.


It's easy to take surgical gloves for granted, to not think too much about what they cost, how well they work for you and whether you could do better on both fronts. For example, our online survey found that nearly 1 in 3 facilities hasn't trialed a new glove in the past 3 years. And that less than 1 in 4 buy gloves designed with such skin-friendly features as aloe. Here's a look at our readers' glove purchasing and use trends.

Standardizing and spending
Buying and shelving more than 1 type of the same surgical supply or instrument tends to be a burden to materials management and a drag on your budget. But only one-eighth of survey respondents say their facilities have standardized their surgical gloves under a single brand. More than half stock 2 or 3 brands. Overall, more than half also stock 4 to 6 sizes of gloves.

Many of those who responded to a question about the annual cost of their facility's glove supply confessed that they didn't know how much was spent. Of those who did provide a figure, the average annual expense was $10,000. Most reported that they're satisfied (and hardly anyone is dissatisfied) with the cost, fit and comfort, usability and durability of the gloves they purchase most often.

One layer is enough for the 42.3% who say they rarely or never double-glove for surgery. Another 32.4% say they double-up for every case or for most cases. While glove manufacturers have promoted products treated with moisturizing additives or other skin conditioning ingredients as gentler on the hands that work in the gloves all day, 76.4% of respondents say they don't purchase them.

2011 Surgical Glove Research Report: Purchasing and Use Trends

In an online survey we conducted this summer, we asked our readers about their surgical glove purchasing and use trends to find out what factors are important to them and what they require in a glove. Here's what 72 of you told us.

How many brands of surgical gloves does your facility stock?
Just 1: 12.5%
2 or 3: 56.9%
4 to 6: 27.8%
7 to 12: 1.4%
More than 12: 1.4%

How many sizes does your facility stock?
Just 1: 0%
2 to 4: 23.6%
4 to 6: 51.4%
More than 6: 25%

When was your last surgical glove trial?
Within the last year: 31%
More than a year ago: 36.6%
More than 3 years ago: 23.9%
More than 5 years ago: 5.6%
Never trialed gloves: 2.8%

Are you planning to trial, standardize or purchase a new type of glove in the next year?
No: 76.8%
Yes: 23.2%

How often does your staff double-glove?
For every case: 12.7%
For most cases: 19.7%
For some cases: 25.4%
Rarely: 29.6%
Never: 12.7%

Do you still stock latex surgical gloves?
Yes: 70.8%
No: 29.2%

Have you, a staff member or a patient experienced or witnessed a latex-glove-related allergic reaction, sensitivity, skin irritation or dryness?
Yes: 48.6%
No: 51.4%

Latex issues
Manufacturers' representatives have pointed out that, in recent years, the surgical glove market has been increasingly shifting its focus toward synthetic, non-latex products. However, 70.8% of respondents say they still stock latex gloves.

"Most of my staff prefer latex powder-free," says Kristine Bedford, RN, BSN, clinical director of the Endoscopy Center of Marin in Greenbrae, Calif. "But we use the latex-free during GI procedures due to their texture, and if we have a latex-allergy patient, which is not very often."

About half of the respondents say that they, a member of their staff or a patient at their facility has witnessed or experienced the effects of exposure to the potentially allergenic latex proteins contained in latex gloves. While such safety concerns are driving a switch to non-latex gloves — 55.6% say they've sought out latex-free, low-powder, powder-free or de-proteinized materials — their cost has a dampening influence on purchasing decisions, too.

"I would love to convert to all non-latex surgical gloves," says a nurse administrator from a Maryland ASC. "How-ever, the price is prohibitive. We only carry a small supply to use for our latex-allergy patients."

The administrator of an Ohio orthopedic facility agrees. "If latex-free surgical glove prices came down significantly, and were comparable to latex's prices, we would trial them immediately."

Another Way Double-Gloving Reduces Infection Risks

Wearing 2 layers of gloves is seen as an infection prevention strategy during a surgical procedure, but can it also reduce the risk of spreading bacteria afterward? Researchers at Georgia State University's Institute of Public Health in Atlanta examined how much, and how often, viral bacteria is transferred to healthcare workers' hands after patient care, as they removed their personal protective equipment. For their study, which was published online in August by the American Journal of Infection Control, they dressed the subjects in contact isolation gowns, N95 respirators, eye protection and latex surgical gloves — alternately single-gloved and double-gloved. They contaminated the PPEs with a harmless virus. Then the subjects removed the PPEs and their hands, faces and scrubs were sampled for the virus. The researchers found that more bacteria were transferred to the subjects' single-gloved hands while removing the PPEs than to hands that were double-gloved.

— David Bernard

Reasons to reconsider
"Research gloves at least once annually," recommends Beverly Kirchner, RN, BSN, CNOR, CASC, president of Genesee Associates in Highland Village, Texas. "Watch for product changes that make gloves safer."

About two-thirds (67.6%) of respondents say their facilities have conducted a surgical glove trial within the past 3 years, but for the remaining one-third it's been longer than that, if at all. Three-fourths aren't planning to trial new glove products, standardize their inventories or add another type to their inventory in the next 12 months, but that's not to say there's nothing that could make them change their minds, and their gloves.

By a large margin, the factor that most respondents say could encourage them to trial (and potentially purchase) a new glove was the promise of a better deal on pricing, as long as the quality and feel of the glove they were switching to was equal or superior to that of the gloves they'd been using. The appeal of a demonstrably more durable product was also mentioned in a number of responses, including those who are still seeking an ideal solution. "Durability needs to improve drastically for healthcare workers' safety," says Stephanie Husted, RN, MSN, CNOR, administrator of Physicians' Surgery Center in Prairie Village, Kan.

Several administrators say they wouldn't be likely to make a change in glove inventory without physicians' fingers pointing the way, by expressing a preference for a more comfortable, better fitting product or complaining about the declining quality of the gloves the facility's been receiving. Of course, organizing a trial might be necessary if the types of gloves a facility regularly orders are unavailable or have been discontinued, or if a change in group purchasing organization affiliation or purchasing contracts occurs.

The end result may be financially advantageous, through the standardizing of your inventory or a re-evaluation and re-negotiation of a standing order. "We just went through a glove trial in the last year," says Brandy Miller, MSN, RN, CNOR, director of Premier Surgery Center in Fort Wayne, Ind. "We ended up securing bulk pricing for the primarily used glove we have in stock."

Related Articles