The ultimate success of minimally invasive surgery hinges on a surgeon's ability to effectively cut and seal blood vessels. Thermal and ultrasonic energies (see "Know Your Energy Options") for cutting and coagulation in laparoscopic procedures have superseded clamping, cutting and tying as surgeons' methods of choice. But no technology is foolproof. Keep these ever-present risks in mind to limit the possibility of unwanted outcomes.
- Thermal spread. It's the main hazard when using electrosurgical instruments, says Resad Pasic, MD, PhD, a professor of obstetrics, gynecology and women's health at the University of Louisville School of Medicine in Kentucky and director of the school's gynecologic endoscopy section. As the jaws of a cutting and sealing instrument are applied to tissue, the heat — and the subsequent tissue dessication from the heat — spreads to adjacent tissue. Depending on how long the energy is applied, it could result in unnecessarily damaged tissue after a few seconds. The higher voltage of bipolar devices tends to create a wider thermal spread of a couple of millimeters. Vessel fusion instruments, on the other hand, which employ lower voltage delivered in pulse fashion, create less thermal spread, usually 1mm or less. When electrosurgical instruments are used selectively, thermal spread can be minimized, says Dr. Pasic.
- Over-reaching. In cutting and sealing, "much of what is associated with injury is user error," says perioperative educator and consultant Brenda Ulmer, RN, MN, CNOR, of Snellville, Ga., a past president of AORN and former director of education for a medical device manufacturer. Cutting and sealing devices have a low learning curve, but a thorough familiarity with the technology's recommendations and parameters is important. Ignoring a manufacturer's directions or overconfidently going beyond them is courting trouble. "With vessel fusion devices, you can grasp and seal tissue up to 7mm in size," says Ms. Ulmer. "But I've seen surgeons try to grasp vessels larger than 7mm." Instruments have been tested and validated to certain parameters. Don't try to do too much or take too big a bite, she says.
- Adjacent anatomy. Over-reaching can also create a problem if a surgeon, working too close to an adjacent structure, grabs a portion of the wrong tissue. Other such mishaps include cutting past the tissue that has been sealed, resulting in a bleed, or failing to adequately seal a vessel by grasping tissue with a clip or suture in it. "If you know your anatomy, though, this is not a big deal," says Dr. Pasic. To be on the safe side, he says, an awareness of the vital structures near where you are working will help to apply energies in a safe manner, safely away from where they are not needed.
- Fire hazards. Bipolar, vessel fusion and ultrasonic instruments don't remain as hot for as long as monopolar electrocautery devices do — plus, they're hand-controlled, not foot-pedal-driven, so there's less risk of unintended activation — but in the seconds after their use, you can't be too careful, says Vangie Dennis, RN, BSN, CNOR, CMLSO, administrative director of the Spivey Station Surgery Center in Jonesboro, Ga. "Just as with any heat-generating device, laying them directly on a paper drape could spark a surgical fire," she says. While specially designed holsters are recommended for monopolar devices, cutting and sealing devices tend to be longer and don't fit as practically. Instead, Ms. Dennis advises, lay a damp towel or 4 x 4 on the Mayo stand or impervious drape, and be sure to set the recently hot device on top of it. Also, she says, "be careful how you pass them. The jaw is serrated and could be considered a sharp."
- A rule for reuse. Bipolar cutting and sealing devices are reusable, but vessel fusion instruments are oftentimes single-use. As they represent approximately $700 in supply costs each, facilities may try to economize by sending them for reprocessing. SUD reprocessing remains a controversial decision that at this point is being made on a facility-by-facility basis. But Dr. Pasic maintains that surgeons should be notified if they're using reprocessed and refurbished single-use devices, as it can be difficult to tell otherwise.
CUTTING CONCERNS: Know Your Energy Options |
Let's review how the 3 most common types of surgical energy-driven cutting and sealing instruments work. 1. Bipolar Bipolar cutting and sealing instruments use the tissue's impedance to electrical current to create the heat that coagulates the tissue. In a bipolar device, the electric current passes between 2 electrodes of the same size on a single instrument. "The bipolar method collapses the walls of the vessels together, creating something of a seal," says perioperative educator and consultant Brenda Ulmer, RN, MN, CNOR, of Snellville, Ga., a past president of AORN and former director of education for a medical device manufacturer. "But it still might need additional support. If the seal opens, it will bleed." Bipolar coagulation offers a level of safety over monopolar electrosurgery. Unlike bipolar energy devices, where both electrodes are at the tip of the instrument and electricity only affects the small amount of tissue between them, monopolar devices use the entire patient as a circuit. The electrical current is dispersed from the small active electrode at the tip of the instrument in the surgical site, through the patient's body, to a larger return electrode affixed elsewhere on the patient, oftentimes on their buttock. Only the tissue in direct contact with the active electrode is subject to the electrical current, as long as the patient remains properly grounded. If the return electrode peels off, however, thermal burns or other electrical injuries may result. "Surgeons need to understand the physics behind electrosurgery" to optimize an instrument's use as well as its safety, says Resad Pasic, MD, PhD, a professor of obstetrics, gynecology and women's health at the University of Louisville School of Medicine in Kentucky and director of the school's gynecologic endoscopy section. He says the technology's accessible learning curve lets surgeons "start cutting and burning without a full understanding of the mechanics." 2. Vessel fusion Vessel fusion devices use radiofrequency energy, a higher electrical current and lower voltage than bipolar devices. They don't just collapse a vessel's walls to form a seal, they reshape the tissue to cut and coagulate simultaneously, which reduces blood loss, says Ms. Ulmer. The current is delivered in pulses, hundreds of times a second. What's more, the forceps in this new-generation electrosurgical device send information on the electrical impedance of the tissue back to a microprocessor in the power generator, which subsequently adjusts the voltage in real time to only deliver the energy that is needed for the task. When cutting and coagulating with a bipolar device, "you wait to see the "snap, crackle, pop,' the tissue blanching, to know it's sealed," says Ms. Ulmer. "With this technology, the computer knows it's sealed, and shuts off." 3. Ultrasonic Ultrasound devices, also known as harmonic scalpels, utilize mechanical energy and high-frequency vibrations on tissue to do the job. While generators exist that can power monopolar, bipolar and vessel fusion devices, ultrasonic technology as yet requires its own unique unit. Ms. Ulmer speculates that a generator that can accommodate any surgical energy is currently in development, an advance that would reduce the amount of equipment necessary in the OR. — David Bernard |