Surgical Video's Next Big Things

Share:

Don't look now, but it might be time to start thinking about replacing your facility's 4K monitors.


Doesn’t it feel like every time you turn around there’s a new and better video system hitting the market? You probably remember that soon after hanging high-definition monitors in your ORs, 4K ultra-high-definition became the gotta-have-it upgrade. Well get ready, because emerging technologies are once again pushing the envelope of what can be seen during surgery, from 4K images combined with 3D technology to packing more pixels on screens with, yes, 8K resolution.

Enhancing 4K with 3D

For many, 4K ultra-high-definition video is the gold standard in the OR. It’s derived from a 3,840 x 2,160-pixel matrix to provide crisp and clear images. The latest 4K systems boast higher-resolution images and several features designed to improve the surgeon’s precision as he moves through the body: the ability to magnify an image on the screen 10 to 30 times with virtually no pixelation; enhanced color profiles with more detail; and the ability to use smaller 5 mm scopes with features such as autofocus that keep images sharp as the surgeon moves the camera within the surgical field.

Neurosurgeon Joshua Bederson, MD, chairman of neurosurgery at Mount Sinai Health System in New York City, notes that the real magic happens when you combine the clarity of 4K video with the enhanced depth perception of 3D images.

SIGHT TO BEHOLD High-definition images projected on big-screen monitors hung around the OR create an immersive surgical experience.   |  Mount Sinai Health System

3D video systems have been around for a while in 2 options: through robots equipped with 3D video or independent, standalone systems where the viewer wears glasses to see the 3D images. However, the lack of resolution with previous 3D systems often left surgeons wanting more. “When we first started using 3D endoscopes, I just sent them back because the resolution was inferior,” says Dr. Bederson. “The decrease in resolution was more limiting than the increase in depth perception.”

Typically used in video microscopes with heads-up displays, 4K-3D technology promises more accurate surgery by providing high-resolution 3D imaging of the structure of tissue, blood vessels and other parts of the anatomy. On the 4K-3D system Dr. Bederson uses, the images can be displayed on both the eyepiece of the microscope and an ultra-high-definition video monitor. Dr. Bederson notes that not only does the technology boast detailed views of the surgical field, but it also has the ability to integrate with other standalone technologies, overlaying data from surgical navigation systems, CT scans, MRI scans and even virtual reality technology on the image of the surgical field to guide surgeons and help them avoid delicate anatomical structures.

Rafael Grossmann, MD, FACS, a general surgeon and healthcare innovator in Bangor, Maine, notes that while 3D imaging may help some surgeons and can “look real” on the screen, it’s still hard to define what, if any, benefits it provides in terms of outcomes or surgical accuracy.

Though Dr. Bederson says that he uses the 4K-3D microscope for complex procedures such as removal of deep-seated brain tumors or treating aneurysms, the technology could also be used for routine cervical and lumbar spine cases, like discectomies. Dr. Bederson notes the technology is still a “very high-tech, expensive platform,” but with more manufacturers looking at how to incorporate 4K-3D images into surgical specialties, he sees it becoming more commonplace.

“The expense is on the microscope side,” he explains. “4K-3D comes down to a camera and a flat screen. If you take out the video aspect of things, you could reduce the price significantly. I have a feeling once the technology is used routinely, it will facilitate increased safety for all sorts of cases.”

Bigger, better images

4K video has been the darling of the surgical world the past few years, but new 8K technology is now starting to hit the market. While standard HD has 2 million pixels, and 4K displays have more than 8 million pixels, 8K has an impressive 7680 × 4320-pixel matrix — or more than 33 million pixels — resulting in images that are almost lifelike.

Though a complete 8K surgical video system (including the towers, scopes and monitors) isn’t yet on the market, researchers in other countries that have begun using 8K have found it promising for complex minimally invasive procedures. In 2018, researchers from Tokyo developed a lightweight 8K ultra-high-definition microscopic camera that was used to simulate ophthalmic surgery in pig cadaver eyes. The authors of the study noted that the 8K images could “increase quantity and quality of microscopic digital images on the monitor, and the 8K UHD images are equivalent to real microscopic observation through eyepieces (osmag.net/KU2ssK).”

With 8K television already popping up on the consumer market, it’s likely only a matter of time before it hits ORs across the U.S., says Dr. Grossmann. Despite this, it may take a while before it fully catches on in surgery, especially as facilities are still working to upgrade their current systems to the latest 4K technologies.

“For most procedures, 4K is very good,” he says. “I think doubling the resolution may make things look crisper, but the question will be how much of a difference does that really make? It may look incredible, but when you’re obtaining information from that image, I’m not sure that it will make a huge difference, especially when you take into account the higher price.”

VIRTUAL REALITY
A New Way of Seeing Surgery
DOSE OF REALITY Rafael Grossmann, MD, FACS, says surgeons will interact with surgical images to perform better and safer surgery.

While you may be looking at getting a new 4K, 3D or even 8K video system in the future, you should also prepare for adding augmented reality to your ORs, says Rafael Grossmann, MD, FACS, a surgeon and healthcare futurist in Bangor, Maine. He says the use of virtual, mixed and augmented reality is going to challenge the current healthcare model within the next couple of years and let surgeons simulate surgical scenarios before and even during procedures.

“Augmented or mixed reality will revolutionize how we perform surgery,” says Dr. Grossmann. “We will be able to interact with images in a more powerful way than we do now.”

There are already some manufacturers making a move into this new landscape. In one augmented reality system used by Joshua Bederson, MD, neurosurgeon and professor and chairman of neurosurgery at Mount Sinai Health System in New York City, surgeons can upload pre-op MRI or CT scans into the system and use the technology to view 3D images of patient-specific anatomy. Dr. Bederson notes that this lets the surgeon identify critical structures to avoid, accurately highlight anatomical targets and even program image-guidance systems to map out the best surgical approach. Being able to overlay the images directly onto the patient can allow for more precise surgery.

Though still not widespread, expect augmented reality to appear in an OR near you within the next few years, says Dr. Grossmann. “From training to diagnostic to treatment, you will see this type of technology being used routinely,” he says.

— Kendal Gapinski

Dr. Bederson welcomes the idea of increased resolution, though it means facilities will need to continue navigating the fine line between having the latest and greatest technology and controlling expenses. “Obviously, budgets are tight, so you must be cognizant of the benefit as it relates to the cost,” he says. “But look at surgical navigation as an example. Before, it was a very expensive luxury for most facilities. Now, some surgeons won’t operate without it.”

The best advice if you’re looking to upgrade video technology is to truly understand how emerging imaging technologies can help surgeons do their jobs better. “Stay current on the latest options, which continue to evolve at a rapid pace,” says Dr. Grossmann. “It’s important to not be blinded when new imaging modalities become available.” OSM

Related Articles