Welcome to the new Outpatient Surgery website! Check out our login FAQs.
Is This Sexual Harassment?
Knowing when incidents have crossed the line and how to handle them if they do.
Mark Peters
Publish Date: May 7, 2011

Sexual harassment puts its victims in an uncomfortable situation, but not all uncomfortable situations are sexual harassment.

You might be surprised to learn which of the following incidents would — and would not — be considered sexual harassment.

How would you respond if this happened in your facility?

No, wouldn't be considered sexual harassment

Yes, would be considered sexual harassment

1. During surgery, a scrub nurse inadvertently knocks an instrument off the stand onto the floor. The surgeon loses his temper and unleashes a profanity-laced tirade against the nurse, her mistake and her clinical abilities.

X

2. Then the surgeon says, "Just what I expect from a woman. I haven't had any decent help since John quit."

X

3. A pre-op nurse complains that an anesthesiologist strokes her arm and calls her "honey" every time he speaks with her. But he's also been seen putting his arm over the shoulder or slapping the back of every member of your staff and squeezing every patient's hand, and he calls everyone "pal," "sport," "sweetie," or other nicknames.

X

4. Your female OR nurses frequently pass the time between cases with sexually oriented discussions, dirty jokes, and tasteless photos and videos on the internet. The lone male OR nurse sometimes joins in the horseplay to get along with his co-workers, but he tells you that his colleagues' behavior offends him.

X

5. A surgeon invites the business office's latest hire over to his house after work or for a ride in his new car.

X

6. That same surgeon points out a mole on the back of her neck and jokes, "Is that your bend-over button?"

X

7. One of your colleagues in hospital administration alleges that the chief financial officer told her, "You have nice assets — you really ought to show them off more." When confronted with this allegation, the CFO, who was foreign-born and is known around the hospital for the scrambled language in his e-mails, protests that his compliment was misunderstood.

X

Sexual harassment's gray areas
Of course, it's also possible that the answers to 1, 3, 5 and 7 could be "This might be sexual harassment, if ... ." Context is critical in every situation. The addition of a few more facts can open an incident to a wider, more costly interpretation.

For example, a surgeon who repeatedly intimidates a particular nurse with sexually oriented conduct because she is a woman (like one who discriminates against a particular race, age or disability) has violated the law, but a surgeon who is abusive to everyone technically has not. It's not illegal to be offensive in the workplace, as long as you're offensive to everyone without exception. We call this the "equal opportunity jerk" defense.

Conversely, an employee who says sexually oriented conduct among her co-workers has created a hostile working environment may be complaining about conduct that would offend the average person, but if they've previously participated in the remarks and joking, there may be some question as to whether the conduct was actually offensive to this particular employee. Both of these aspects play a role in determining whether harassment has occurred.

Harassment on the basis of sex violates the anti-discrimination laws set forth in Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964. Most states have similar legislation as well. Under the federal law, unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors and other verbal and physical conduct of a sexual nature constitute harassment when:

  • an employee's submission to this conduct explicitly or implicitly becomes a condition of employment,
  • an employee's submission to or rejection of this conduct impacts employment decisions, or
  • this conduct interferes with an employee's performance or creates an intimidating, hostile or offensive environment.

Sexual harassment can include touching in more than a casual, friendly way, propositions or advances, commenting about body parts, joking about sex (either the act or the gender), or using an employment position to threaten, suggest or imply sexual favors.

What must you do?
From a practical standpoint, it's not necessary for you to decide whether an incident is a legally actionable case of sexual harassment. That's the job of the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (or the corresponding state agency) and the courts. Your role is to determine whether your employees' behavior has violated your facility's anti-harassment policy and what, if any, discipline or corrective action would remedy the situation. Ideally, taking action at the earliest possible opportunity can prevent unresolved complaints from ever winding up in front of government agencies or a judge and jury. Some things you can do:

  • Create a zero-tolerance policy. A proactive response to violations of your anti-harassment policy requires, first and foremost, that your facility has adopted such a code of conduct before an incident arises. Your policy should include a statement expressing zero tolerance for harassment in the workplace for any reason, on any basis. It may list a range of protected categories (not limited to gender alone) and examples of intimidating or disruptive behavior (not limited to sexually oriented conduct alone).
  • Promote non-punitive reporting. Ensure that, along with the anti-harassment policy, your surgeons and staff understand the confidential, retaliation-free complaint process that offers them the ability to address potential violations of the policy.
  • Act swiftly. Investigate complaints promptly, consistently and thoroughly. Doing nothing is the most dangerous response to reports of harassment. Question the employee who has lodged the complaint as well as the alleged harasser and any witnesses to the incident. Be sure to document your responses to each complaint.

Does every complaint require an investigation? Absolutely. Keep in mind, however, that responses might vary depending on each individual situation. Not everything is going to be a 5-alarm fire. You've got to review each incident on the facts, but you've got to take each one seriously. Follow up with employees who've filed complaints to inform them of the outcomes.

If your investigation determines that an incident has violated your facility's conduct policy, you must attempt to resolve the situation by appropriately correcting the offender's behavior and providing a remedy to the offended. Possibilities include an apology meeting between the employees, a disciplinary interview, a sensitivity training session or even a rearranged schedule that prevents the offended from having to work with the offender.

On the Web

What's more important?
Sexual harassment isn't just an employment law issue. It's a patient safety, quality of care, quality of life and accreditation issue as well. In Sentinel Event Alert 40, published in July 2008, the Joint Commission included sexual harassment among the intimidating and disruptive behaviors that — through "a history of tolerance and indifference," not to mention victims' hesitance to be whistleblowers — can lead to a ripple of negative effects such as medical errors, dissatisfied patients and poor employee retention. Don't let it go unchallenged at your facility.

DID YOU SEE THIS?