In 2006, the Surgery Center of Reno, a joint venture with St. Mary's Hospital in Reno, Nev., was performing 500 cases a month — and losing money. A little over a year later, after it partnered with our ASC management company and recruited 22 new physicians, we turned a -15% return on investment to a 110% return on investment. How'd we do it? In addition to a shift in management structure, from majority hospital ownership to majority physician ownership with business operations run by our corporate partner, one major key to our success was the addition of spinal surgery to our facility's case mix. Today, about 25% of our facility's profits come from spinal procedures, which make up only 4% of the cases we do.
Whether you're planning a new surgery center venture or looking to diversify the caseload at an existing facility, spine surgery presents an excellent opportunity for profitability and future growth. But developing a new spine program also requires a sizable upfront investment in capital equipment and top-notch surgeons who are comfortable doing complex procedures in an outpatient setting. Here's how to make this low-volume, high-profit specialty work for you.
Why spine?
Advances in technology and treatment, such as minimally invasive surgical instruments and techniques and high-tech surgical microscopes, have let many spine procedures that once were available only on an inpatient basis migrate to the outpatient setting. The market is expected to grow exponentially in the coming years as these technologies continue to improve, more physicians become comfortable doing spine procedures on an outpatient basis and the large population of baby boomers grows older. Some of the most common outpatient spine procedures performed at my center are:
- anterior cervical discectomy;
- anterior cervical discectomy and fusion;
- foraminotomy (cervical posterior and lumbar);
- lumbar microdiscectomy; and
- lumbar laminectomy.
While spinal surgery involves a huge upfront investment in equipment, the favorable reimbursement environment for spine procedures lets you maintain high margins while performing fewer cases. Adding spine also brings new physicians to your facility who can add or contribute to other profitable service lines, such as orthopedic and pain management cases — 2 specialties that are also experiencing considerable growth in the outpatient market.
Assembling your spine team
The first step to adding spine cases is to identify and recruit dedicated surgeons who want to perform procedures in an outpatient setting and are at ease doing so. A successful spine program requires neurosurgeons and orthopedic surgeons who can work together to conduct complex surgeries and achieve the goals of improved quality of care, patient satisfaction and profitability.
How do you convince world-class surgeons to join your fledgling spine program? Show them you've got a world-class facility that offers them something they can't get in the practice, hospital or ASC where they currently work. Surgeons as a whole, and spine surgeons in particular, need to be comfortable in their setting. Ease of scheduling, a top-notch support staff, the opportunity to do fewer cases while maintaining high margins and the ability to have direct input in management and equipment purchasing decisions are some of the perks that will lure spine surgeons to your facility.
In a multispecialty surgery center like our Reno facility, it's important to cross-train your nurses and techs so they're able to assist on a variety of different types of surgeries. Spine and orthopedics go hand in hand, so when adding these specialties you may want to train staff members specifically to work on those cases. That way they'll become comfortable and skilled working with the unique instruments these specialties require. Anesthesia personnel should be comfortable with the ASC model and use alternative post-op pain management strategies to get patients moving sooner after surgery. For example, our anesthesia providers use the anti-inflammatory drug Toradol (ketorolac tromethamine) instead of narcotics after anterior discectomies.
In addition to recruiting excellent surgeons and staff, you may want to consider bringing a corporate partner on board to help with the challenges of adding a complex and potentially lucrative new specialty to your case mix. That way, you can focus on delivering the best quality of care to your patients and leave the business side of things to the experts. If you decide to team up with a corporate partner, review and investigate management companies that have experience and a successful track record with developing ASC spine programs. Your business partner should be able to:
- negotiate insurance contracts to maximize reimbursements for your spine cases;
- secure equipment and supply purchases at the lowest possible cost and ensure efficient use of facility resources;
- facilitate communication among the physician-investors, administrators and support staff;
- promote quality improvement initiatives and create a desirable work environment for the staff and a healing environment for the patients; and
- take only a minority share of the business, letting physician-investors maintain majority control over the facility.
6 Equipment Essentials for Spine |
1. Operating table. The ideal OR table for spine surgery should:
In my experience, the Allen frame performs comparably to the standard OSI Jackson table for non-instrumented cases, with some additional benefits: It's smaller, can be adapted to a regular table, folded into a neat unit for storage and is considerably less expensive. Estimated cost: $35,000 for the Allen frame; $135,000 for the OSI Jackson table 2. Surgical microscope. Two important factors to consider when shopping around for a neurosurgical microscope: It should offer a small footprint and provide the operator assistant with maximum maneuverability of the eyepieces. Some surgeons may request a high-end microscope with image guidance capacity. Keep in mind that these microscopes are better suited for intracranial cases, and most of them cost more than $250,000. Estimated cost: $100,000 3. Intraoperative imaging. You'll need a high-end C-arm fluoroscopy unit that provides excellent visualization for lumbar and cervical cases, as well as the flexibility to be used in orthopedic and pain intervention cases. I recommend you purchase a new or relatively new reconditioned unit. Older C-arms tend to result in poor visualization and increased surgeon dissatisfaction and have a higher rate of intraoperative equipment failure, requiring costly repairs. Estimated cost: $180,000 to $200,000 for a new unit 4. Instrumentation trays. Many vendors offer complete sets of excellent quality cervical and lumbar trays. Choose the systems that your surgeons find most comfortable and that offer the best retractor systems, but keep them lean — make sure the trays contain only the instruments that your surgeons absolutely need. Start with 2 cervical and 2 lumbar trays; this arrangement allows appropriate backup and rapid turnovers. Add to the systems as your case volume increases. Estimated cost: $10,000 to $15,000 each 5. Surgeon headlight. Simply put, you want the most comfortable headlight with the best illumination. Identify the top 3 headlights, host a weeklong demonstration and purchase the best performer as judged by the surgeons, since they're the ones who are going to be wearing them. Estimated cost: $12,000 to $15,000 each 6. Surgical drill. Typically, surgical drills are either air-driven or electric, and they're all similarly priced. You'll need at least 2 of them so you have a backup if one goes down. Estimated cost: $15,000 each for standard pneumatic drills. — James J. Lynch, MD, FACS |
Outfitting your ORs
If you want to develop a state-of-the-art spine program for your ASC, your capital equipment purchases should support that commitment. Be prepared for a costly upfront investment in big-ticket items like OR tables and imaging equipment. But while your initial outlay may be large, keep in mind that a well-organized and financially successful spine program can recoup this investment in a relatively short time.
The equipment requirements for an outpatient spine program typically fit into 2 categories: equipment for standard spine procedures and equipment for such advanced surgical procedures as minimally invasive surgery and minimal fusion. Most facilities will have just 1 OR for spine procedures, since it's such a low-volume specialty. For 1 OR, you'll need an operating table, a surgical microscope, a C-arm fluoroscopy unit, 2 cervical and 2 lumbar instrumentation trays, a surgical headlight and 2 surgical drills. See "6 Equipment Essentials for Spine" on page 28 for pricing estimates and purchasing advice on these items.
When equipping a spine program in an ASC, the process is similar to outfitting a hospital operating room, but don't simply replicate what your surgeons use in the hospital. Often, ASC procedure rooms and ORs are smaller — and so are the budgets. Carefully evaluate which pieces of equipment best meet your surgeons' preferences, are necessary for the procedures they perform and physically fit in your space. Here are several key elements to remember:
- Physician comfort. Consult with your surgeons, learn their preferences and obtain their feedback before making major purchasing decisions.
- Space constraints. You're equipping a surgery center, not a large hospital. Use equipment that makes smart use of your available space.
- Durability. Use state-of-the-art equipment, but be wary of equipment that may become obsolete. The key question is, will this expensive tool or device quickly become dated, or is it a more lasting innovation that my surgeons need to better perform their cases?
- Price. Use corporate or group purchasing where you can to get bulk purchasing discounts.
As your center's spine program grows and your surgeons become more experienced, you may wish to offer more advanced, minimally invasive spine techniques, which use table-mounted tubular retractor systems or other retractor systems available on the market with expanding port systems. Be mindful of 2 things when your surgeons request this equipment: It tends to date very quickly, and it often falls out of favor among surgeons looking to use the newest systems. Arrange for your vendor to bring in such high-end equipment, including minimally invasive lumbar spine instrumentation cases, on a case-by-case basis for an agreed-upon fee. That way you won't spend thousands of dollars on equipment that is barely or never used.
Down the line
Once you've established your spine program, examine demand in your market and the quality of programs meeting that demand. Growing your program is less a matter of handling a high volume of cases than handling the right cases. Identify service areas that are underserved in your community and consider whether adding spine to your facility would improve your margins and enhance the area's health care.