Advice from Architects

Share:

Taking the time to properly plan your project is the key to saving time and money down the road.


A few sobering facts about the building that will house your surgery center:

  • It's the biggest capital line item in your project, and it will have the smallest impact on quality outcomes.
  • There are no refunds - and it will cost more than you anticipated.
  • And you only have one chance to get it right.

We spoke with architects and asked them to share with us the secrets to designing a successful surgical facility.

Team-building
When you recruit your team of experts, our architects advise you to look first and foremost for healthcare experience, especially with surgical facilities. They also agree that getting the developer, architect, engineer, contractor, lawyer, equipment planner, interior designer, consultants and lenders involved as early as possible can help reduce future change orders.

"Everyone wants to reduce change orders. If you work with a team of professionals, you can deal with most changes in the design phase," says Mike Gordon, an architect with Gordon & Associates of Mount Dora, Fla. "It's much easier and more cost-effective to erase a line during the design process than to tear down a wall."

Before hiring a general contractor, check his credentials with the state registrar of contractors, and find out if anyone's filed complaints against him, says Neil Terry, an architect with the Orcutt/Winslow Partnership in Phoenix. Check references, too, says Lynn App, an architect from Englewood, Ohio. "Talk to former clients and visit completed projects," she says. Ask questions like these:

  • Did the design meet your needs?
  • Was the project completed on schedule and on budget?
  • How was the general working relationship?
  • Did you and the architect work well together?

In addition to finding an architect with surgery center experience, you might want to consider an architect with experience in your state, as state regulations vary.

Develop your own team of decision-makers, including physicians, administrators and nursing staff, but don't go overboard. "It works well if you have two to five key decision-makers," says Mr. Cantrell. "Include an administrator and the director of nursing, who can be involved in every planning step. Then bring the recovery nurses into the meeting on the PACU and peri-operative nurses into the meeting on the ORs."

What to Look for in an Architect

We asked W. Wayne Lee, vice president of facilities development for Health Inventures, what you should keep in mind when selecting and engaging an architect. Here are his eight best tips:

  • Look for experience first - medical and surgery center preferred.
  • Interview at least three; see some of their work and talk to previous clients.
  • Insist on meeting the architect for your project.
  • Before you hire him, confirm with the architect that he can work within your budget and schedule.
  • Be aware that the architect will employ other design engineers, such as civil engineers and interior designers. Give your input on the interior design. Ask the architect why he chose each consultant and what experience the consultant has to qualify him for this project.
  • Use an American Institute of Architects (AIA) contract form. Any licensed architect or lawyer who deals with real estate or construction will have access to the AIA agreement templates. Get copies at www.aia.org or most good book stores.
  • The architect's services include design and engineering of the building, as well as assisting the owner through construction to building acceptance.
  • Architects typically are compensated as a percentage of the total construction cost - 7 percent to 8 percent of the construction cost is average. Renovations of existing buildings will often result in higher architectural fees as a percentage of construction cost than all-new construction.

- Dan O'Connor

New vs. existing spaces
Renting or buying an existing building can save money, but our architects warn that you can't cheaply turn every building into a surgery center. "Look for one that is classified as institutional occupancy. Business occupancies, such as office buildings and even medical offices, have very different codes," says Mr. Terry. "You may to add a sprinkler system and fire-protection walls." "If you're above the first floor, you risk inconveniencing other tenants when you tear up their ceiling to get the gas line into the OR. It can get to be cost-prohibitive," says John Cantrell of the Orcutt/Winslow Partnership.

Other unexpected costs to consider: a covered entrance, emergency power, air filtration, and accessible parking and delivery areas. To prevent unexpected costs, have an architect look at any space you are considering before you enter into an agreement for it, suggests William Massingill, an architect with Polkinghorn Group Architects, in Austin, Texas.

"The days of build-it-and-they-will-come are over. Before you start designing anything, you must determine if you have enough cases to keep the center alive and profitable," says Mr. Gordon.

Start by having a good idea of the kind and number of procedures you'll do, and the estimated reimbursements for them, Mr. Terry says. In a multi-specialty center, you can estimate about eight cases to 10 cases a day per OR, or around 900 cases per year per OR.

Your procedure mix will determine the applicable guidelines for your ORs. Mr. Terry explains how the American Institute of Architects' regulations classify ORs into A, B or C based on the type of anesthesia used in the room:

  • Class A is the least restrictive and is used for local anesthesia - basically your procedure rooms.
  • In a class B room, you can administer conscious sedation.
  • Class C, used for general anesthesia, requires the largest room size and has the most restrictive guidelines.

With the feasibility study, you must also determine the licensure and certification you're seeking, so decide on those early. "You must determine which licensure, certification and accreditation your center is seeking in order to complete a program assessment. Your state public health department will determine the minimum construction standards. More regulations may be required depending on which certification process you see," says Jeff Eckert, architect with Eckert Wordell Architects in Kalamazoo, Mich.

Your total costs should include

  • construction (contractor, bricks and mortar)
  • professional fees (architect, engineers, equipment planner, lawyer, consultant)
  • equipment;
  • furnishings and fixtures;
  • administrative fees (permits, connection fees, surveys, regulatory fees and borrowing fees like appraisals, points and inspection costs) and
  • land costs (site and site development costs).

Green Building Guide for Healthcare

A new tool is available to help healthcare professionals build facilities that are healthy for people and the environment. The Green Guide for Health Care (GGHC), released in November, is the first green-building best-practices guide created specifically for healthcare.

The GGHC is a voluntary self-certifying system, adapted from the U.S. Green Building Council's LEED rating system and modified to meet the needs and priorities of the healthcare industry. The guide, however, is not a LEED rating system or a product of the U.S. Green Building Council.

The LEED rating system for green building awards a point if you get five percent of the building's energy from renewable sources on site (for example, solar or wind power), says Kristi Ennis, a senior associate and sustainable design director at Boulder Associates in Boulder, Colo.

The GGHC gives you a point for using one percent renewable energy.

Facilities can choose from 168 points inlcudings points for eliminating persistent toxic chemicals, such as mercury and dioxin, from building materials. And unlike the LEED's system facilities, the GGHC also awards points for ecological operations once the building is complete, including the use of environmentally safe supplies and cleaners.

"Aside from the money you'll save in electricity and water, studies show that green building can result in higher productivity in staff and reduced absenteeism. The non-toxic environment can also improve the health and satisfaction of patients and staff," says Ms. Ennis.

- Kristin Royer

Space programming
During the programming phase, develop a list of rooms and determine their number, sizes and functions, from entry, business and support areas, ORs, and pre- and post-op rooms.

Most architects agree that determining the number of pre-op and recovery rooms is as critical as the number of ORs because the same potential for bottlenecking exists there. "In the morning, you have more pre-op than post-op patients," says Mr. Gordon. "If you have two pre-op rooms and two recovery rooms per OR, equip them with the same beds and supplies and you can use them interchangeably." Using this system, you can also centralize the nurses station and share one station between the two areas, says Mr. Cantrell.

This phase is also when you begin to talk about patient, staff and material flow. "The greatest impact that we as healthcare design specialists have is in designing for optimal staffing levels. Saving one full-time employee through efficient design can mean a savings of over one million dollars over the term of the finance for the facility," says John Hrivnak, an architect at Altus Architectural Studios in Omaha, Neb.

Mr. Terry advises you go on field trips to existing facilities so you can walk through and, in addition to finding out what you like and dislike, see the flow and efficiency-improvement opportunities of the center.

Advice for Expansion Some tips from architects if you're planning to expand.

"Put the core support functions in the center of the facility and design ORs and waiting areas around that so you can eventually expand those areas out if necessary."

William R. Massingill
Polkinghorn Group Architects

"When designing the facility, consider long-term goals. If you don't have room in your budget for everything you want, make good plans for the future. Have a master plan and say this is phase one and do preliminary planning for future phases from the beginning."

Lynn App
E. Lynn App Architects

"Of the 260 surgery centers we've designed, less than 10 percent actually physically expanded. There are often more cost-effective ways of increasing your revenue without having to add onto the facility, like expanding hours to add evenings and Saturdays."

Todd E. Larson
Marasco & Associates

"It's better to shell in future ORs if your volume is on the cusp. You can always outfit the rooms 18 months to 24 months down the road."

Jack A. Amormino
AMB Development Group

- Compiled by Kristin Royer

"Your architect should understand your daily activities and have innovative ideas for how to allow for more efficient work flow," says Tim Riddle, architect with Boulder Associates, in Boulder, Colo. "For example, where do you put the gurney during a procedure? Many facilities wheel it out to the?sterile corridor, because this is the way it has always been done. Designing a place to store it in the OR may save time and prevent overcrowding in the hall."

Also consider the patient experience, says Mr. Cantrell. The presence of natural light can improve overall patient satisfaction, but it can difficult to bring in everywhere. Choose?places where it is most appreciated, such as?in the waiting room and recovery areas, says Mr. Riddle. Other patient-friendly amenities include private consultation areas and Internet access in the waiting room.

"Some clients want to go overboard and create a lavish spa-like setting for patients, but there is a fine balance," says Mr. Massingill. "Investors want a quick return on their investment, and the more money that goes into the center, the longer it will take to see a return."

Schematic design
During this phase, the architect draws up the floor plan - and the state agency might already be involved, depending on your location. "We recommend the state's being involved at the beginning so it can interpret codes and regulations," says Mr. Eckert. "By involving these individuals early in the process, we have found this approach will many times shorten and guarantee a successful review process."

Once the floor plan is finished, architects begin to add details, like cabinetry and finishes, and lay out equipment locations. "A lot of this is done with computer programs and 3-D models to give the client a feel for how it will look and function," says Mr. Terry.

Follow these tips and, with state and local approval in hand, you'll be on your way to completing what will hopefully be a successful surgery center.

Putting Your Project Out to Bid

Many physicians look at building a surgery facility as they look at buying a consumer product, like a can of cola. They go to a designer, who says he can build their surgery center for a guaranteed maximum price of $1 million; if they can afford that, they go ahead without thinking much about the quality and quantity of what they're getting. Although it can add weeks to your timeline, competitively bidding a project gets you the most value for your money. Here's advice on doing that.

- Pre-qualify the potential contractors. Use a limited invited-bid list of about a half-dozen pre-qualified contractors who have experience in the size and type of facility you are building.

- Submit highly detailed drawings. To get the most accurate estimate, your architect must provide the contractors with detailed and complete construction documents. The contractor will make assumptions about any missing information, which could inflate the price or, worse, lead to a change order down the road. It's not enough for the drawings to say "nails" - the contractor will need to know how many, and what kind to make an accurate estimate. - Paul W. Stegenga, AIA

Mr. Stegenga (writeMail("[email protected]")) is president of Stegenga & Partners, PC, in Alpharetta, Ga.

Related Articles